Chương 5
“Yes.”
“I thought if I stayed, I could control what happened next.”
“Could you?”
“No.”
She sat across from him.
The cottage refrigerator made a faint ticking sound. Someone had left a ceramic bowl of apples on the counter, each one waxed to a theatrical shine.
Thomas rubbed his thumb against the side of his glass. “When we were children, Vivienne used to take blame for things I did. Once I broke a window in the west stairwell. She told Dad she’d done it because he was already angry with me about school.”
“How old were you?”
“Nine. She was thirteen.”
“Did she keep doing it?”
“For a while.”
“And did you ever take blame for her?”
He looked down.
Nora waited.
“No,” he said.
The answer was quiet enough to contain years.
“She ran this place while I got to leave,” he continued. “She handled Dad’s illness, Mom’s panic, the staff, the foundation. I came home for meetings and criticized her decisions.”
“That doesn’t explain the cup.”
“I know.”
“It may explain why you’re trying to find an innocent version of it.”
He nodded.
Nora pressed both palms against the table. “My father used to tell me that explanations and excuses were cousins who wore each other’s coats. I hated that sentence.”
Thomas almost smiled.
“He said it whenever I was late.”
“That sounds like Frank.”
“He was late to everything.”
“That also sounds like Frank.”
For a few seconds, they were themselves again.
Then Thomas’s phone vibrated.
He looked at the screen and turned it facedown.
“Vivienne?” Nora asked.
“My mother.”
“What does she want?”
“For us to tell the deputies it was a family misunderstanding.”
“Can we do that?”
“No.”
“Would you?”
“No.”
This time he answered quickly.
Nora believed him.
It was not enough to repair the evening, but it kept her at the table.
The sheriff’s office arranged for Elliot to meet a child forensic interviewer two days later at an advocacy center in Poughkeepsie. Elise accompanied him. Nora stayed away because the interviewer had asked family members who had discussed the event with him not to be present unless necessary.
Nora spent those hours at the museum, though her director told her she could take the day.
Work gave her objects that behaved according to physics.
A silver teapot did not lie about being moved. A shipping crate did not ask for loyalty. If a painting arrived with a new puncture in the canvas, Nora could compare the condition report, contact the carrier, and document what had changed.
People were harder because damage traveled through memory.
She was cataloging a collection of mourning jewelry when Priya appeared beside her desk with two coffees.
“I brought decaf,” Priya said, placing the cup down carefully. “It has your name and three warning labels.”
Nora looked at it.
Priya noticed. “Right. Bad choice.”
“No. Leave it.”
“You don’t have to drink it.”
“I know.”
Priya sat in the visitor’s chair. Her red scarf was wrapped twice around her neck, though the museum’s basement office was overheated.
“Elliot finished the interview,” she said.
“Mom called you?”
“She called me because she thinks you’ll hear worry in her voice and assume the worst.”
“I always hear worry in her voice.”
“Exactly.”
“How was he?”
“Hungry. Apparently the interviewer had only pretzels, and he considers pretzels an insult.”
Nora smiled despite herself.
Priya leaned forward. “He gave a consistent account. Your mother said the interviewer wouldn’t discuss details, but Elliot told her afterward that he saw Vivienne bring her cup from the sideboard, wait until you stood, then switch it with yours.”
“Did he say she put anything in it?”
“No.”
“Did he see anyone else touch it?”
“No.”
Nora looked at the mourning brooch beneath the task lamp. A curl of brown hair had been sealed behind glass more than a century earlier. The donor’s family had no idea whose hair it was.
“Thomas spoke to Vivienne’s lawyer this morning,” she said.
Priya’s eyebrows rose. “She has a lawyer already?”
“Rebecca told her the foundation could no longer represent her personally.”
“And what does Thomas think?”
“He says hiring counsel doesn’t mean guilt.”
“He’s right.”
“I know.”
“You sound angry that he’s right.”
“I’m angry that every neutral fact feels like something I’m supposed to use against myself.”
Priya was quiet.
Nora picked up the decaf and held it without drinking. “The lab won’t have results for weeks.”
“Maybe sooner if the sheriff prioritizes it.”
“Or maybe there’s nothing in the cup. Maybe she really switched it because of caffeine.”
“Then why lie?”
“Because she’s proud. Because Elliot embarrassed her. Because she moves things at Bellwether all day and doesn’t think she owes explanations. Because people are ridiculous.”
“All possible.”
“You’re not helping.”
“I’m not supposed to decide for you.”
Nora looked at her friend.
Priya had been present when Thomas proposed on a rain-soaked dock the previous spring. She had hidden behind a stack of rented kayaks with Nora’s phone and filmed only the first ten seconds before accidentally covering the lens with her thumb.
Now she said, “You don’t need to know whether Vivienne wanted to hurt you in order to know she violated something.”
“What?”
“Your ability to choose what entered your body.”
The words made Nora set down the coffee.
She had been resisting that sentence because it sounded larger than a cup. It sounded like something that could not be repaired by an explanation.
Thomas called that evening.
He had returned to Manhattan for a meeting with the foundation auditors. Nora stayed at Elise’s house with Elliot.
“The preliminary field screen showed something,” he said.
Nora stood in her childhood bedroom, looking at glow-in-the-dark stars still fixed to the ceiling.
“What does something mean?”
“They won’t tell me. Calder said the cup was sent to the state lab for confirmation.”
“Did he say what kind of substance?”
“No. He said the initial test was not conclusive.”
May you like
“Did Vivienne’s cup test positive too?”
“I don’t know.”
