Chương 7

It was also enough time to erase a great deal.
Walter pressed Judith’s name.
Simon moved around the chair. “Think carefully.”
Walter looked at him. “I should have done that this afternoon.”
Judith answered on the second ring.
At eight the next morning, Claire returned to Naomi’s office through the underground garage.
Naomi’s firm occupied two floors of a building overlooking the Schuylkill River. On Sundays the reception desk was empty, the lights dimmed, and the conference rooms smelled faintly of carpet cleaner. A junior attorney brought coffee and a legal pad, then closed the door without asking about the wedding.
Claire appreciated him for almost a minute before realizing he was trying not to stare at her left hand.
Naomi slid a printed still image across the table.
It showed a man in a dark coat entering Claire’s apartment hallway at 3:13 the previous afternoon. His face was turned away from the camera. He carried nothing visible.
“Building management released that?” Claire asked.
“No.”
“Then where did you get it?”
“A resident across the hall has a doorbell camera.”
“How did you know?”
“I asked your building manager which neighbors complained most often about deliveries.”
Claire looked at the image again. “I don’t recognize him.”
“Look at the shoes.”
Black leather, narrow toe, pale edge along the sole.
Claire had seen them beneath a table at the rehearsal dinner.
“Daniel Cross,” she said.
“Who?”
“Simon’s executive assistant.”
“You’re certain?”
“He wears custom shoes with gray welting. Walter once made fun of them.”
Naomi turned over a second image. The man was leaving at 3:18. The right side of his face was visible.
Daniel Cross had spent most of the wedding standing near the ballroom entrance with an earpiece.
Claire sat back.
“What do we do?”
“We document, preserve, and avoid dramatic confrontation.”
“Can we call the police?”
“We can make a report. They will ask what was taken, whether you can prove it existed, whether Cross had authorization to use Walter’s key, and whether the material on the drive belonged to you.”
“It was in my apartment.”
“The drive was yours. Much of the data may not have been.”
“So he can steal it because I shouldn’t have had it?”
“No. I’m telling you the situation is legally untidy, not morally invisible.”
Claire pushed the photograph away. “I’m getting tired of that distinction.”
“You may be tired of it for several years.”
Naomi opened another folder. Inside were printouts of messages between Claire and Walter.
“How did you get those?”
“Walter authorized an outside forensic review at two this morning. His counsel sent us a preservation request and disclosed that Simon’s department had collected communications involving you.”
Claire read the first page.
Some were harmless. Dinner plans. Medication reminders. A photograph of a lamp Claire wanted Walter to stop pretending he liked. Others were taken from conversations with her mother.
He says the house will be mine if he dies first, Claire had written five months earlier.
Elise had replied, I wish both of you would stop discussing death like a closing date.
Farther down, Claire found the message Simon had shown Walter.
If this lasts a year, everything changes.
The line appeared alone.
“What was the rest?” Naomi asked.
Claire looked away.
“What was the rest, Claire?”
She tried to remember. “It was about my old employment agreement.”
Naomi waited.
“When I resigned from Mercer, I had a twelve-month non-solicitation clause. Walter wanted me to consult for one of the foundation projects, and I said if we waited a year, everything changed.”
“Can you retrieve the conversation?”
“My phone was replaced after I dropped it in the bath. The backup failed.”
“Your mother?”
“She deletes messages.”
“Of course she does.”
Claire read the isolated line again. Without context, it looked like a plan. Wait a year. Secure something. Leave.
“Walter saw this?”
“Simon’s team gave him a packet.”
“How many messages?”
“Twenty-seven.”
“Out of how many?”
“Thousands.”
Claire covered her mouth with one hand.
Naomi turned to another page. “Did you ever tell your mother you would leave Walter after a year?”
“No.”
“Did you discuss inheritance?”
“Yes.”
“Did you discuss whether the marriage would improve your finances?”
“Yes.”
“Did you ever say you would stay if he became seriously ill?”
Claire looked up. “What kind of question is that?”
“The kind opposing counsel will ask if this becomes litigation.”
“I told him I would stay.”
“That wasn’t my question.”
Claire stood and walked to the window. The river below was the color of dull steel.
Six months earlier, after Walter had fallen in the bathroom and cracked two ribs, she had called her mother from the hospital parking garage. She had been exhausted, frightened, and furious at Walter for refusing to use the cane his doctor prescribed.
I don’t know if I can do this for ten years, she had said.
Her mother had replied, You don’t know if you can do anything for ten years. Nobody does.
Claire told Naomi.
“Was it in a message?”
“A call.”
“Could it have been recorded?”
“Not by me.”
“Did you say anything similar in writing?”
“I don’t remember.”
“Try.”
Claire turned from the window. “I loved him.”
Naomi’s face did not change. “That is not a password that opens every locked fact.”
“I know.”
“Good. Because Walter’s mistake does not make every choice you made wise. If you want to protect yourself, we need the version that includes the parts you dislike.”
Claire sat again.
“I was afraid,” she said. “Not of caring for him. Of disappearing into it. He had nurses available, but he hated strangers in the house. He wanted me at every appointment. If I went to lunch without him, people looked at me like I’d abandoned a patient.”
“Did you tell him?”
“Sometimes.”
“What did he say?”
“That I was borrowing trouble.”
“And the money?”
May you like
“I knew I would be comfortable if he died. I hated myself for finding comfort in that.”
Naomi closed the message folder.