Part 5
Margaret knew that expression from church women who wanted prayers but not questions.
A hospital television played a cooking show without sound. Someone had decorated the nurses’ station with paper snowflakes. A boy in a soccer jersey vomited into a blue bag while his father said, “Almost done, buddy,” with no evidence to support it. Life continued even here, with its ugly chairs and vending-machine crackers and people scrolling phones because fear needed somewhere to put its thumbs.
Margaret wanted her own phone. Not for comfort. For facts. For timestamps. For proof she had none of.
A social worker named Denise arrived wearing a cardigan printed with tiny foxes. She had tired eyes and a careful voice. She pulled a rolling stool close to Margaret.
“Mrs. Voss, I’m going to ask you a few questions.”
“It’s Ms.,” Margaret said automatically. Then, because it sounded vain under the circumstances, “Sorry. Margaret is fine.”
“No need to apologize.”
“There is, usually. I’m from a family that apologized when furniture creaked.”
Denise smiled, not too much. Good social workers did not spend smiles recklessly.
Margaret told her what happened. She did not embellish. The truth was strange enough without decoration. She described the baby on the floor, Claire and Drew in the doorway, the locked attic, the emergency device. She did not call Claire a monster. She did not call Drew a coward, though the word kept knocking against her teeth.
Denise listened with her pen still for long stretches.
When Margaret finished, Denise said, “Claire says she found you holding Ava in the attic after you became confused.”
Margaret nodded. “I assumed she would.”
“She says you’ve shown memory problems.”
“I forget why I enter rooms. I once put the mustard in the freezer. I am sixty-nine, not made of marble.”
“Have you ever been diagnosed with cognitive impairment?”
“No.”
“Do you live with Drew and Claire?”
“In the in-law suite downstairs. It used to be the garage before we made bad financial decisions with good intentions.”
Denise wrote something.
Margaret rubbed the side of the paper cup with her thumb. “I sold my condo after Drew lost his job in the pandemic. The house was too much for them. Claire was pregnant the first time then. That pregnancy ended.” She looked toward the curtain. “I paid off part of the mortgage. They converted the garage. I moved in. It was supposed to help everybody.”
“Does it?”
Margaret almost answered yes. Then she looked at Drew, who had not once crossed the hallway to sit beside her.
“It helped the mortgage,” she said.
Denise’s pen moved again.
A nurse came through the curtain carrying a small vial. Margaret leaned forward, then stopped herself. Need made people look guilty in public.
“How is she?” Margaret asked.
The nurse looked at Denise, then at Claire, then back to Margaret. “She’s stable. Mildly low temperature when she came in, but improving. The doctor will explain.”
Stable. The word should have held more comfort. Margaret had seen stable marriages collapse, stable jobs disappear, stable ladders tip when someone reached one inch too far.
Claire stood quickly. “Can I go in?”
The nurse’s face changed in that hospital way, soft but blocked. “The doctor is with her right now.”
“I’m her mother.”
“I understand.”
Drew came over finally. He sat beside Claire, not Margaret. His shoulder nearly touched his wife’s, but not quite. That gap held a whole marriage.
Margaret’s knee pulsed. Her hands smelled faintly of Ava’s blanket and attic dust. She wanted to wash them and feared losing that evidence of the child.
The police officer from the house returned with another officer, a woman named Patel. They took Margaret’s statement again in a family consultation room with a poster about handwashing curling at one corner. Officer Patel asked clearer questions than the first officer, and Margaret appreciated her for it until the questions began to expose all the places where Margaret’s certainty had no witnesses.
“You did not see who placed the baby on the floor?”
“No.”
“You did not see anyone lock the door before you were inside?”
“I heard it after.”
“Is there any camera in the attic?”
“No.”
“In the hallway?”
“I don’t know. Drew installed one by the front door. Claire didn’t like cameras inside.”
“Did either of them threaten the baby directly?”
Margaret stared at her. “They left her there.”
“I’m asking for exact words.”
Exact words. As if cruelty lived only in sentences.
“Claire said, ‘Then stay down there with her.’”
Officer Patel wrote it down.
When they let Margaret leave the room, Drew was waiting outside. Claire was not with him. For a moment he looked seventeen again: too tall for himself, eyes rimmed red, one hand worrying at the seam of his jeans.
“Mom,” he said.
Margaret stopped.
“I messed up.”
It was such a small phrase for such a large thing that she almost walked past him. But he was her son. Her body stopped before her pride could instruct it.
“Is Ava yours?” she asked.
He flinched. Not from surprise.
“Drew.”
He looked toward the nurses’ station. “Not here.”
“Is she yours?”
His jaw worked. “I don’t know.”
The answer loosened something terrible.
Margaret sat in the nearest chair because standing had become too ambitious. “You don’t know.”
“Claire had—before we—there was a time when we separated for a few weeks.”
“When?”
“Last spring.”
“You told me she was visiting her sister.”
“She was. After.”
Margaret watched a nurse tape a holiday card to the desk. It had glitter on it. The glitter fell every time someone bumped the counter, little festive scraps landing among insurance forms and specimen labels.
“Why was Ava on the attic floor?” she asked.
Drew put both hands over his face. His voice came through his fingers. “Claire said she couldn’t look at her. She said if I made her keep pretending, she’d walk out and never come back.”
May you like
“So you put the baby on the floor?”
“No.” His hands dropped. “No, Mom. God. No. Claire had her. She was saying all this stuff, and I was trying to calm her down, and she carried Ava upstairs because you were coming up, and then she—she set her down.”
